The Falconer's Voice

Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel

FIXATION+ON+REPRESENTATION%3A+While+%E2%80%9CFantastic+Beasts%E2%80%9D+provided+commendable+representation+by+casting+Carmen+Enojo%2C+a+black+woman%2C+as+the+president+of+the+wizarding+government+of+America%2C+it+lacked+diversity+in+the+form+of+LGBT+characters.+Despite+high+expectations+for+this+changing+in+%E2%80%9CThe+Crimes+of+Grindelwald%2C%E2%80%9D+this+installment+in+the+%22Fantastic+Beasts%22+series+will+not+deliver+the+representation+for+which+fans+were+hoping.
FIXATION ON REPRESENTATION: While “Fantastic Beasts” provided commendable representation by casting Carmen Enojo, a black woman, as the president of the wizarding government of America, it lacked diversity in the form of LGBT characters. Despite high expectations for this changing in “The Crimes of Grindelwald,” this installment in the

FIXATION ON REPRESENTATION: While “Fantastic Beasts” provided commendable representation by casting Carmen Enojo, a black woman, as the president of the wizarding government of America, it lacked diversity in the form of LGBT characters. Despite high expectations for this changing in “The Crimes of Grindelwald,” this installment in the "Fantastic Beasts" series will not deliver the representation for which fans were hoping.

Warner Brothers Pictures

Warner Brothers Pictures

FIXATION ON REPRESENTATION: While “Fantastic Beasts” provided commendable representation by casting Carmen Enojo, a black woman, as the president of the wizarding government of America, it lacked diversity in the form of LGBT characters. Despite high expectations for this changing in “The Crimes of Grindelwald,” this installment in the "Fantastic Beasts" series will not deliver the representation for which fans were hoping.

Vishwa Bhatt and Krishna Nair

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






While many Harry Potter fans are excited for the upcoming release of “The Crimes of Grindelwald,” the sequel to “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them,” a considerable amount of controversy surrounds the new film.

The film will take place one month after the events of “Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them,” the first movie in the “Fantastic Beasts” series. The main antagonist, Gellert Grindelwald (Johnny Depp) has escaped from prison, and a young Albus Dumbledore (Jude Law) needs the help of his former student Newt Scamander (Eddie Redmayne) to track Grindelwald down.

Depp played the villainous Grindelwald in “Fantastic Beasts” as well, quickly becoming one of the most well-known controversies surrounding the “Fantastic Beasts” franchise.

Depp was cast just months after he was accused of domestic violence against his former wife, Amber Heard, in 2016. Since then, many have been calling to have someone else take over his role. Despite this, Depp is continuing his role in the “Fantastic Beast” films.

Many have voiced their anger on this, using the example of “All the Money in the The World,” in which director Ridley Scott replaced Kevin Spacey with Christopher Plummer after Spacey faced allegations of sexual abuse, even though a majority of the scenes had already been shot with Spacey. However, the budget and time to do that is not something that every film has the luxury of having.

Director David Yates, J. K. Rowling, and Warner Bros. have all released statements defending the decision to keep Depp on, primarily citing the joint statement Depp and Heard made as their argument. The couple’s statement acknowledged that “there was never any intent of physical or emotional harm.”

Rowling, who is writing the screenplay for the film, has stated that “agreements have been put in place to protect the privacy of two people, both of whom have expressed a desire to get on with their lives…. Based on our understanding of the circumstances, the filmmakers and I are not only comfortable sticking with our original casting, but genuinely happy to have Johnny playing a major character in the movies.”

In the end, the majority of viewers’ decisions to watch the movie will not be influenced by controversy such as this one, especially with younger viewers.

Freshman Bhakti Ramani says, “If Johnny Depp is a professional man and serious about his job, then he should continue playing his role in the movie. We don’t know the full truth, so we shouldn’t be making any conclusions that will affect the production of the movie.”

Another source of conflict about the movie comes from a decision that was announced on January 31. Director Yates said in interview that Dumbledore’s sexuality would not be explicitly shown.

Rowling revealed that she had “always thought of Dumbledore as gay” in 2007. Since then, the majority of Harry Potter fans have embraced this interpretation of Dumbledore.

Dumbledore is the only character in the series who was confirmed not to be heterosexual. While sometimes morally gray, he was written as someone who always worked for good and believed in the power of love. This positive representation of a gay character was extremely empowering for many fans, regardless of whether they were part of the LGBT community or allies.

However, some criticized this “coming-out” as too little, too late. Dumbledore was revealed to be gay the year that the final installment of the Harry Potter series was published, a full two years after his character died in “The Half-Blood Prince”. This made it impossible for future works to include such representation with Dumbledore’s character, and therefore followed the “bury your gays” trope.

The announcement that the “Fantastic Beast” movies would include a young Dumbledore brought new hope for fans, especially since Rowling has stated that Dumbledore was in love with Grindelwald himself when he was younger. In a film that is set to feature both men opposite each other, allusions to previous attractions could provide character depth and strengthen the plot.

Despite this, upon being asked if Dumbledore would be openly gay, Yates stated that Dumbledore would “not explicitly” be portrayed as gay in “The Crimes of Grindelwald.”

This seems to go in direct contrast with what Rowling said in 2016 about the films, saying, “As far as his sexuality is concerned … watch this space,” in reference to the “Fantastic Beasts” movies. Outraged fans quickly took to Twitter and angrily tweeted at both Yates and Rowling about the interview.

Freshman Ashnu Cassod says, “I think that Dumbledore definitely should be shown as gay, especially since J. K. Rowling said he was and most people accepted that. Harry Potter is a huge franchise, so having LGBT representation would impact a lot of people. The fact that Dumbledore is gay doesn’t have to be a huge part of his character, but I think erasing that is a mistake on the filmmakers’ part.”

However, not everyone is as concerned with this omission.

Freshman Riya Patel says, “I don’t think it’s necessary to see a gay Dumbledore. First of all, we don’t know how comfortable the actor of Dumbledore is with portraying a gay character. Additionally, if his sexuality isn’t going to affect the plot, I don’t see why it needs to be included.”

Some of the accusations being leveled against the film include that Dumbledore’s sexuality is being hidden to make the film more palatable for countries that are not as accepting of openly gay characters. In other words, some are worried that this decision was made with money in mind so the movie performs well even in countries like China and Russia.

Rowling has replied to the backlash she has received for this. In her typical style, she criticized the people sending her abuse “about an interview that didn’t involve me, about a screenplay I wrote but which none of the angry people have read.” She also implied that there is chance for this representation in later movies, as the entire “Fantastic Beasts” series is planned to have five parts.

Another source of criticism came with the trailer’s release on March 13, which showed a group of wizards apparating, or magically transporting themselves, onto Hogwarts grounds.

Previous installments in the Harry Potter series have clearly established that wizards cannot apparate into Hogwarts, and many fans pointed this out and came up with theories of their own as to why this was included. Others have been quick to write it off as a plot hole.

Freshman Ava Guardado says, “Personally, I don’t think it’s a big deal. There were some flaws in the original movies, too, and this probably won’t affect the plot that much in the end.”

Jessica Williams, former Daily Show correspondent and good friend of Rowling herself, has assured fans that Rowling and Yates know what they are doing and that the scene was intentional. However, not everyone is convinced.

“The Crimes of Grindelwald” is set to premiere on November 16, 2018.

What are your opinions on the controversies surrounding the film?

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

About the Writers
Vishwa Bhatt, Staff Writer

Vishwa Bhatt is freshman in Journalism I at Monroe Township High School. She enjoys reading and writing articles for the class and in her free time. Vishwa also enjoys reading books, short stories, and poems, as well as listening to most musical genres. She is interested in everything from “Harry Potter” to “Hamilton,” and she can be found geeking out about either at any given point. Her amazing friends are always there to cheer her up and boost her self confidence. For this reason, she would like to remind everyone that: “You are braver than you believe, stronger than you seem, and smarter than you think.” -A.A. Milne

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Krishna Nair, Staff Writer

Krishna Nair is a freshman at Monroe Township High School. She joined Journalism because she was interested in the process of making a newspaper. She also joined because of her love of reading and writing, both of which she loves equally. Music is another one of her passions, and she can be found listening to anything from Disney songs to “Hamilton.” She makes time for her friends whenever possible, though she’s just as likely to punch them as she is to hug them. She likes to think she brightens their days as much as they brighten hers.
She’d like to remind her readers that when in doubt, go to the library (or check out the school newspaper).

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
1 Comment

One Response to “Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel”

  1. CN on April 5th, 2018 7:23 PM

    I’m a huge fan of the franchise and I’m really annoyed by the ‘controversies’. Depp and Heard have already reached a settlement. Fantastic Beasts is a family film and incorporating an openly gay Dumbledore will be tricky especially for a franchise that is bigger overseas than in America. I’m gay and I don’t care whether he’s openly gay or not. As for diversity, as an audience from outside the US, I don’t care, just give us great movie and we’ll watch whatever the races of the actors are.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel

    Entertainment

    James Patterson and Bill Clinton co-write ‘The President is Missing’

  • Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel

    Entertainment

    Spotify removes ‘hate conduct’ policy after facing backlash

  • Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel

    Entertainment

    ‘Detroit: Become Human’ offers a look into a future with androids

  • Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel

    Entertainment

    Sail into theaters to see ‘Adrift’

  • Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel

    Entertainment

    ‘Deadpool 2’ has the comedy and heart superhero movies need

  • Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel

    Entertainment

    Kanye West returns to hit-making and drops ‘Ye’

  • Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel

    Entertainment

    Calpurnia releases new single ‘Greyhound’

  • Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel

    Entertainment

    Top 5 binge-worthy crime shows on Netflix

  • Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel

    Entertainment

    ’13 Reasons Why’ season 2: Controversies fixed

  • Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel

    Entertainment

    Season 5 of ‘Agents of SHIELD’ proves superhero shows are more than just action

Monroe Township High School News
Controversies surround upcoming ‘Fantastic Beasts’ sequel